British-Conservatism 12:22 PM 12-11-2008
Originally Posted by Charlemagne:
Wrong! The British do not exclusively pay the wages for all the MEPs. Germany contributes as much if not more than the British. That's before factoring in the contributions of the other member states too.
How many British MP's do you think £4.7 billion would pay for?
[Rep]
Charlemagne 12:29 PM 12-11-2008
Originally Posted by British-Conservatism:
The UK's net contribution to the EU last year was £4.7 billion.
That is quite some saving if we leave.
Not on my Nelly are we leaving. We are here to stay. There is too much riding on it to leave now.
You'd better get used to it. All the struggling just makes the pain worse.
[Rep]
Robin 01:36 PM 12-11-2008
Originally Posted by British-Conservatism:
The UK's net contribution to the EU last year was £4.7 billion.
That is quite some saving if we leave.
It`s bigger than that.
[Rep]
angelman 03:07 PM 12-11-2008
Originally Posted by Northumbrian:
But the Welsh have their own language, and that is one of the criteria for nationhood.
So America, Australia, new Zealand etc shouldn't be independent countries?
[Rep]
Gillespie 06:23 PM 12-11-2008
Originally Posted by Charlemagne:
Why do you think we created the role of MEP? All MPs will eventually be phased out within 10-20 years. They will be replaced by MEPs who will report directly to Brussels thus conveniently bypassing Westminster.
I'm suprised you didn't know this.
Following this logic to the next level, why not phase out both Westminster and the EU, establish a 'World Parliament' run by the UN and instead elect a single British representative to this every 5 years? Of course, countries like China and India would be entitled to more 'MWPs' on account of their greater populations, but it is only 'democratic' that they should dictate internal policy in this country. And just think how much money could be saved by reducing the number of politicians in the country to 1.
I think you should abandon your support for the EU, which is clearly passé, and campaign for this instead.
[Rep]
Northumbrian 07:12 PM 12-11-2008
Originally Posted by Gillespie:
Yes - Cornwall also has its own language that no-one ever speaks. Just like Wales!
Take it you've never been to Wales, then? I've heard people speaking Welsh to each other in Rhayader, for example.
[Rep]
Northumbrian 07:16 PM 12-11-2008
Originally Posted by angelman:
So America, Australia, new Zealand etc shouldn't be independent countries?
Duh, you sound confused. I said language is one of the criteria for nationhood - I didn't say it was the only thing.
But using your argument, you must agree England should be an independent country, as that's where English originates.
[Rep]